Cookie Time
By Nancy Honig
Adult Development and Aging Agent
Wild West District
I’ve just finished up my fifth program on Cookie Basics and received lots of comments from people regarding things they had been doing wrong for years when baking cookies but didn’t know it. I will share a couple of highlights from the program. If you want a booklet with some of the recipes I made and shared and more written information stop by the Wild West District Extension Office in Hugoton between 9-12p.m. or 1-5 p.m.
Cookies are made primarily with butter, margarine or shortening. Fats play a major role in the spread of a cookie – whether a cookie keeps its shape or flattens in the oven. Shortening and margarine are stable, and will help cookies keep their original unbaked shapes. Shortening also melts at a higher temperature than butter, so it remains solid longer giving the batter time to rise and set before it spreads.
Butter melts at a much lower temperature than other solid fats — it melts at body temperature, resulting in a “melt-in-your-mouth” burst of flavor. Cookies made with butter tend to spread out. The amount of fat also affects the cookies: in general, more fat equals flat, crispy cookies while less fat equals puffier, cake-like cookies. Be aware that whipped spreads are not suitable for baking.
How the fat is incorporated, or creamed, also makes a difference. A lot of recipes call for creaming the butter and sugar together until light and fluffy. Why bother? If you use cold butter together with the sugar, the tiny sharp sugar crystals actually cut into the butter, creating very, very small bubbles, and those bubbles will make it easier for other ingredients to integrate into the batter. If the butter is melted or too soft, it tends to separate, and not incorporate as well. Cream the sugar and fat together at a relatively high speed until they are light and fluffy, then reduce the mixer speed and slowly and completely incorporate the eggs and any other liquid, then finish by adding the dry ingredients a little at a time, scraping the sides of the bowl as you go.
Add dry ingredients slowly. It is best to do this in three installments. Flour absorbs moisture, relatively slowly. If you work in about 3 batches, you’re going to allow time for the batter to actually form.
Like fats, sugars liquefy in the oven. The type and amount of sugar used plays a big role in cookie performance. White sugar makes a crisper cookie than brown sugar or honey. If you lower the amount of sugar called for in a cookie recipe, the final baked cookie will be puffier than its high-sugar version.
The darker the sugar you use, the chewier the cookies are going to be, because brown sugar is coated in molasses. Molasses is the liquid that remains after sugar crystals have been extracted from concentrated cane juice. Molasses loves moisture. Cookies made from brown sugar will continue to absorb moisture from the air after baking, helping to ensure that they stay chewy. Increasing the ratio of brown to white sugar also creates a more tender cookie.
For best quality only use pure vanilla extract which is produced by macerating chopped beans in a solution of alcohol and water. In the U.S. real vanilla extract must contain 35% alcohol and 13.35 ounces of beans per gallon. Imitation extract is made from wood and other stuff. Vanilla flavoring, is a combination of imitation and pure extracts. When using Mexican vanillas be aware that some come from tonka bean extract. Tonka bean extract, contains coumarin and is a major component of artificial vanilla flavorings in Mexico. Coumarin, a chemical that’s been banned by the FDA as a food additive. Coumarin is a blood thinner that can cause liver damage and is related to warfarin, which is found in some blood thinners. Eating foods with coumarin can increase the risk of bleeding for people taking blood thinners.
Look for Mexican vanilla with vanilla bean listed in its ingredients. You can also check the price, as cheaper vanilla might not be authentic. Imitation vanilla is often labeled in Spanish, while FDA-regulated products have labels in English
Here is a tip for making your own vanilla. But a word of caution: it takes about six months before you can use it. Buy a bottle of vodka. Take 3-4 vanilla beans, split them down the middle and place inside the bottle. Store in a dark, cool, dry place for 6 months. You will have delicious vanilla to use for baking.
The holidays are here! Time to get baking!