Kansas State University


Extension Entomology

Sugarcane aphid

This year, the warm weather has led to an early development of SCA on volunteer sorghum stubble along the Gulf Coast, something noted in a blog on Feb. 26. Alates (winged aphids) produced by these populations may have arrived in Kansas over the past week, as evidenced by infestation of sorghum in the greenhouse at the experiment station in Hays. Winged aphids can travel hundreds of miles in a matter of days when conditions are right, even though it is basically a suicide mission at this time of year. Based on the infestation patterns we had over the past two years, I have been advising early planting as the cheapest insurance policy – now I am not so sure. I have also been saying how lucky we were that the aphid arrived in Kansas so late in the season in both 2014 and 2015.  I should clarify here that it is not unusual for aphids to colonize our greenhouse in cold winter months, even though there is clearly no chance of them colonizing anything in the field.  It has been commented that we rear aphids here and that we could have been careless and caused the infestation.  I agree this cannot be ruled out entirely, but we have have been rearing SCA continuously for the last 2.5 years without any such occurrence.  In late January, when weather was much colder, we had Rhopalosiphum padi begin infesting both sorghum and millet  – and this aphid was not being reared on the station.  In fact, there has probably not been a single year over the past ten when we have NOT had spontaneous infestations of some aphid in the dead of winter; these have included green bug, Russian wheat aphid and Sitobion avenue, although R. padi is by far the most common.

What does this mean for the Kansas sorghum crop this year? It is hard to say, but two very different scenarios are conceivable. In the best case, these early populations will be brought under control by natural enemies either before they can spread to this year’s sorghum crop in south Texas, or soon thereafter by judicial insecticide treatments. Most of the southern crop will probably be planted with a seed treatment, so this may serve as a critical barrier to further population expansion, for a few weeks anyway. But there is also the risk of more aphids coming from Mexico, which is not unlikely given that management of SCA has generally been very poor south of the border. However, if management of SCA is effective in south Texas and this early outbreak either crashes naturally or is well controlled, it could mean that the inevitable resurgence of aphids actually occurs later in the season than it otherwise would have without the early outbreak, resulting in a Kansas situation not unlike the past 2 years where infestations develop late enough to have a reduced impact. This is our best hope.

In the worst case scenario, in the absence of a population crash, these early aphids could spread into newly planted sorghum across the south, a lot of which is just emerging right now, and then northward, putting all sorghum in Oklahoma and Kansas at risk from the seedling stage onward. Fortunately, it tends to be difficult for aphids to establish on small plants under Kansas summer conditions – excessive heat or a single punishing rainfall event can physically kill most of the aphids on a seedling. However, all aphid movement is highly weather-dependent, and the weather is looking more and more unpredictable with el nino conditions in effect, etc. We will continue to monitor the situation – if the worst case scenario seems to be unfolding as we approach planting dates in Kansas, it may be advisable to plant with an insecticide seed treatment, something I would not normally recommend. So lets hope for the best, and prepare for the worst.

Winged and wingless SCA
Winged and wingless SCA

-J.P. Michaud

3 thoughts on “Sugarcane aphid
  1. I just posted this to the Texas Sugarcane Aphid News site at http://txscan.blogspot.com/2016/03/kansas-aphid-find-does-not-mean-early.html . Pat Porter.

    News went out today that sugarcane aphids have been found in Kansas, but there is more to the story and the details may be important. The report is here. The report says that the aphids were found in a greenhouse, not in the field, and it goes on to discuss the early finds of aphids along the Gulf Coast and suggests the Kansas aphids flew in from the south.

    Actually, we don’t have many winged aphids in Texas yet; the colonies are still primarily composed of wingless aphids, and winged adults will not be found in great numbers for a while longer. It is possible that the aphids remained in the Kansas greenhouse or nearby greenhouse all winter, and a greenhouse discovery does not mean that the aphids arrived from the south this year (or overwintered locally in the wild and infested the greenhouse this spring).

    Texas A&M AgriLife Extension Entomology has nine overwintering study sites on the High Plains, and Dr. Ed Bynum, Extension Entomologist in Amarillo, examined his overwintering cages in Bushland today. His cages are the most northerly of the nine sites and he reported finding no aphids on Johnsongrass that was just beginning to sprout. Pat Porter, Extension Entomologist in Lubbock, dug Johnsongrass yesterday and found no aphids on rhizomes or green buds. The remaining eight overwintering study sites will be examined in the next couple of weeks.

    Reports from Texas have the aphid as far north as Hill and Comanche counties. Dr. Charles Allen, Associate Department Head, Department of Entomology, reported seeing sugarcane aphids on Johnsongrass near San Angelo last week. However, intense rainfall forced him to abandon the site and he did not collect any aphids. But since we all know sugarcane aphids when we see them, Tom Green County can be listed on the map of positive counties.

    The bottom line is that the aphids are farther north in Texas this year than we have seen in the past, but this does not mean that winged aphids have already spread from the Gulf Coast across the plains to Kansas.

    1. I will reply to this in more detail tomorrow on the Melanaphis list serve. I will say that the aphids infesting the greenhouse are not of local origin, and it is common for our GH to be infested with winged aphids of other species (BCOA especially) in the dead of winter, when there is no possible local source.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe By Email

Get every new post delivered right to your inbox.

This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.